Review Form

Please complete this review form offline and enter into appropriate fields on the Web form. Give reasons that support your answers rather than simply checking boxes.

1. Does the paper address issues related to aspects of human-level intelligence, complex cognition, or similar topics? Does it discuss these issues from a cognitive systems perspective?

   Highly related Somewhat related Not related

2. Do the authors present a problem or approach that extends or clarifies the capabilities of cognitive systems, or increase our understanding of their operation, in substantial ways?

   Major extension Reasonable extension Minor extension

3. Does the paper make clear claims about the approach to cognitive systems? Such claims can take many forms, but they should be stated unambiguously in accessible language.

   Clear claims Vague claims No claims

4. Do the authors present convincing evidence that supports their claims? Such evidence can take different forms, but it should lead a reasonable person to conclude the claims are correct.

   Very convincing Somewhat convincing Not convincing

5. Does the paper's writing and organization present its ideas to readers effectively? Can moderately informed readers understand the main contributions and reconstruct the results if desired?

   Very effective Somewhat effective Not effective

6. Do you have other comments that support your overall evaluation or do you have detailed suggestions for improving the paper?

7. Based on the above comments, do you think the paper should be accepted for publication? If you favor conditional acceptance, please itemize the changes necessary for publication.

   Accept paper Conditional accept Accept as Poster Reject paper